Home builder's plans may enjoy copyright protection

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that a custom home designer and builder who brought an action against a competing builder and designer could possibly have a claim in violation of the Architectural Works Copyright Protection Act for similar plans. The designs in this case were for Centennial Style Homes in Williamsburg. The City of Williamsburg limits permissible architectural styles.
The Appeals Court noted that the designs of the two builders shared many similarities including a two story rectangular main body, a walk-out basement, gabled roof featuring dormers, single-story wings flanking the main body of the residence and a detached three-car garage connected to the main body of the residence by a covered breezeway. The interior floor plans of the two designs also share similarities including a foyer flanked symmetrically a dining room and a library and a separate "friends" entryway. In addition, both interior plans have a dining room, kitchen and a "keeping room", all configured in the same width.
The Court of Appeals overturned a lower District Court decision which dismissed the suit. The Court of Appeals indicated that the District Court erred by setting out to detect the disparities or engage in an analytical dissection of the protected and unprotected elements of the design. The Court of Appeals said the District Court should have determined whether the ordinary observer - unless he set out to dissect the disparities - would be disposed to overlook them and regard their aesthetic appeal as the same. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Lead Counsel
  • MSBA
  • sl-badge
Email Us For A Response

How Can We Help You

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Frederick Office
170 West Patrick Street
Frederick, Maryland 21701

Phone: 301-732-7675
Phone: 301-668-5111
Fax: 301-668-2770
Frederick Law Office Map

Silver Spring Office
12114B Heritage Park Circle
Silver Spring, Maryland 20906

Phone: 301-732-7675
Phone: 240-833-2284
Fax: 301-942-8296
Silver Spring Law Office Map

Upper Marlboro Office
14452 Old Mill Road
Suite #301
Upper Marlboro, Maryland 20772

Phone: 301-732-7675
Phone: 301-736-5432
Upper Marlboro Law Office Map